Location: 30°N 48.5°E
This page is under construction
This “delta” is unique as it concerns two major rivers and several local rivers from the Zagros mountains. In that sense, it is different from the Nile or other deltas where a single river splits up into several branches. The total sea-front width of the delta is around 140 km covering three modern countries (Kuwait, Iraq, Iran). Considering the limited geomorphological and archaeological information, and the recent history of this area, our task is nearly impossible (!) but thanks the Martin Sauvage’s recent work (2020) and Heyvaert (2013) and Sanlaville (1989), we can provide a rough picture of geomorphological evolutions of the delta since ancient times.
Both the Tigris and the Euphrates, but also the other local rivers, brought huge volumes of sediment during the past five millennia. The figure shows that in 2500 BCE, both main rivers still had separate outlets. The famous city of Ur was near the outlet of R Euphrates. Lagash was on an ancient track of R Tigris, but the river moved to the north, gradually filling the northern lobe shown in the figure above. Around 1000 BCE, both major rivers had their outlet in the area of modern al-Qurnah, where they still converge today in extensive marshlands. From that time until the present, sedimentation has caused the outlet of the lake (R Pasitigris, now called Shatt el-Arab) to extend further towards the sea.
Let’s start with the following descriptions provided by the ancient authors:
Strabo (15, 3), (https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Strabo/15C*.html ):
“4. Now Susa is situated in the interior on the Choaspes River at the far end of the bridge, but its territory extends down to the sea; and its seaboard is about three thousand stadia in length, extending from boundaries of the Persian seaboard approximately to the outlets of the Tigris. […] Polycleitus says that the Choaspes, the Eulaeus, and also the Tigris meet in a kind of lake, and then empty from that lake into the sea; and that there is an emporium near the lake, since, on account of the cataracts, [dams] purposely constructed, the rivers cannot receive the merchandise that comes in from the sea nor bring down any either, and that all traffic is carried on by land; for the distance to Susa is said to be eight hundred stadia. Others, however, say that the rivers which flow through Susis meet in one stream, that of the Tigris, oppose the intermediate canals of the Euphrates; and that on this account the Tigris, at its outlets, has the name of Pasitigris.
5. Nearchus says that the coast of Persis is covered with shoal-waters and that it ends at the Euphrates River; and that at the mouth of this river there is an inhabited village which receives the merchandise from Arabia; for the seaboard of the Arabians borders next on the mouth of the Euphrates and the Pasitigris, the whole of the intervening space being occupied by a lake, that is, the lake that receives the Tigris; and that on sailing up the Pasitigris one hundred and fifty stadia one comes to the raft-bridge that leads from Persis to Susa, being sixty stadia distant from Susa; and that the Pasitigris is about two thousand stadia distant from the Oroatis; and that the inland voyage on the lake to the mouth of the Tigris is six hundred stadia; and that near the mouth there is an inhabited Susian village, which is five hundred stadia distant from Susa; and that the voyage inland from the mouth of the Euphrates to Babylon, through a very prosperous land, is more than three thousand stadia. Onesicritus says that all the rivers empty into the lake, both the Euphrates and the Tigris; but that the Euphrates, again issuing from the lake, joins with the sea by its own separate mouth.”
Pliny (6, 26 & 31), (http://attalus.org/translate/pliny_hn6b.html ):
“31. […] Then comes a shallow stretch of water like a marsh which nevertheless is navigable by way of certain channels; the mouth of the Euphrates; a lake formed in the neighbourhood of Charax by the Eulaeus and the Tigris; then by the Tigris they reached Susa. […] when the two streams [of R Tigris] have reunited, the river is called Pasitigris. Afterwards it is joined by the Choaspes from Media, and, as we have said, after flowing between Seleucia and Ctesiphon empties itself into the Chaldaean Lakes [this is confirmed in 6, 26], and broadens them out to a width of 62 miles. Then it flows out of the Lakes in a vast channel and passing on the right-hand side of the town of Charax discharges into the Persian Sea, the mouth of the river being 10 miles wide. The mouths of the two rivers used to be 25 miles apart, or as others record 7 miles, and both were navigable; but a long time ago the Euphrates was dammed by the Orcheni and other neighbouring tribes in order to irrigate their lands, and its water is only discharged into the sea by way of the Tigris.”
Arrian (8, 41-42), (https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/ancient/arrian-bookVIII-India.asp ):
“39. […] Then when the flood duly returned, they sailed out, and anchored in a river called Oroatis, greatest, according to Nearchus, of all the rivers which on this coast run into the Ocean. […]
41. Then after traversing five hundred stades they anchored in the mouth of a lake, full of fish, called Kataderbis : at the mouth was a small island called Margastana. Thence about daybreak they sailed out and passed the shallows in columns of single ships ; the shallows were marked on either side by poles driven down, just as in the strait between the island Leucas and Acarnania signposts have been set up for navigators so that the ships should not ground on the shallows. However, the shallows round Leucas are sandy and render it easy for those aground to get off ; but here it is mud on both sides of the channel, both deep and tenacious ; once aground there, they could not possibly get off. For the punt-poles sank into the mud and gave them no help, and it proved impossible for the crews to disembark and push the ships off, for they sank up to their breasts in the ooze. Thus then they sailed out with great difficulty and traversed six hundred stades, each crew abiding by its ship ; and then they took thought for supper. During the night, however, they were fortunate in reaching deep sailing water and next day also, up to the evening ; they sailed nine hundred stades, and anchored in the mouth of the Euphrates near a village of Babylonia, called Didotis ; here the merchants gather together frankincense from the neighbouring country and all other sweet-smelling spices which Arabia produces. From the mouth of the Euphrates to Babylon Nearchus says it is a voyage of three thousand three hundred stades.
42. There they heard that Alexander was departing towards Susa. They therefore sailed back, in order to sail up the Pasitigris and meet Alexander. So they sailed back, with the land of Susia on their left, and they went along the lake into which the Tigris runs. It flows from Armenia past the city of Ninus, which once was a great and rich city, and so makes the region between itself and the Euphrates ; that is why it is called ‘Between the Rivers.’ The voyage from the lake up to the river [Eulaeus] itself is six hundred stades, and there is a village of Susia called Aginis ; this village is five hundred stades from Susa. The length of the voyage along Susian territory to the mouth of the Pasitigris is two thousand stades. From there they sailed up the Pasitigris through inhabited and prosperous country. Then they had sailed up about a hundred and fifty stades they moored there, waiting for the scouts whom Nearchus had sent to see where the King was. He himself sacrificed to the Saviour gods, and held an athletic meeting, and the whole naval force made merry. And when news was brought that Alexander was now approaching, they sailed again up the river ; and they moored near the pontoon bridge on which Alexander intended to take his army over to Susa. There the two forces met ; […]”
Marcian (1, 21), (Schoff 1927):
“21. From the eastern mouth of the river Tigris to Charax Spasini 80 stadia. Off this coast lies an island called Apphana, which some include in the sailing course of Arabia Felix, counting 35 islands in that course. From Charax Spasini to the mouths of the river Mogaeus 700 stadia. From the river Mogaeus to the bay of Pelode [Coenosus] 400 stadia. On this bay and in the neighbouring district dwell the Elymaei, who are of the region of Susiana. Off the coast of this bay lies the island of Taxiana. From this bay to the mouths of the river Eulaeus 690 stadia. Inland on this river is the city of Susa, the metropolis of Susiana. From the river Eulaeus to the [sandy] shoal 110 [stadia]. From the sandy [shoal] to the mouths of the river Oroatis 1450 stadia.”
Let’s now try to list the rivers and places from West to East. Places are listed from upstream to downstream. Note that, early 324 BCE, Nearchus travelled from East to West and sailing from the sea upstream some rivers, we will therefore meet him on several places (Vincent, 1797).
R Euphrates = R Euphrates, around 2800 km long, flowing on the western side of Mesopotamia, on Khor al-Zubayr with an ancient outlet on Khor al-Subiya, west of Bubiyan Island (Kuwait). The following places may be considered as ports on R Euphrates:
- Ur, Uri, Sumerian Urim, North Port & West Port = Tell el-Muqayyar, with “two off-river basins enclosed within the walls of Ur” (acc. to Blackman, 1982, p 92) (Curtis, 2008).
- Modern Tell Abu Tbeirah, 15 km east of Ur, dated 2900-2000 BCE (D’Agostino, 2014).
- Kissik, Kisig, Kuara = Tell al-Lahm, 33 km SE of Ur, dated 2900-2000 BCE (Wikipedia, Curtis, 2008).
- Modern Jedeidah, 54 km SE of Ur, probably operational around 2000 BCE (Sauvage, 2020, p 319).
- Modern Kirbasi, 103 km SE of Ur, probably operational around 1500 BCE (Sauvage, 2020, p 319).
- Pliny’s Teredon, Teriton, Arrian’s Didotis, Diritotis, Ptolemy’s Adarou, Marcian’s Adarupolis, on R Euphrates = very uncertain location north of Bubiyan island, said to have been founded around 600 BCE. (Salles, 2012).
It is observed that places tend to emerge in synchrony with the progression of river sedimentation at the mouth of R Euphrates.
Akarum, Agarum, Ichara, Ikaros, Icarus insula, Marcian’s Apphana insula? Island located in front of the ancient outlet of R Euphrates, and belonging to the archaic Dilmun empire = Failaka Island (Kuwait) (Pawlicki, 2015).
R Tigris = R Tigris, around 1750 km long down to the modern confluence with R Euphrates at al-Qurnah. R Tigris appears to have altered its course from the vicinity of Lagash to its present course further north, likely between 2500 and 2000 BCE. The ancient outlet of R Tigris was in a large lake and marshland called Chaldaicus Lacus by Pliny (6, 31).
Chaldaicus Lacus = The large lake in which R Tigris, R Eulaeus and even R Euphrates flowed (Arrian, Strabo, Pliny, Marcian) extended possibly from al-Hammar and al-Qurnah down to Basra. This lake has now mostly been reclaimed and remnants are found at lake Khor al-Hammar and lake Hawr al-Hawiza near ad-Dayr. Its outlet to the sea was called R Pasitigris (modern Shatt el-Arab), (Sanlavile 1989, Cole 2007).
R Eulaeus, Ulai, Ulaya, Choaspes = R Karun, the outlet of which moved around 80 km south-eastward from the area of ancient Chaldaicus Lacus to modern Korramsharh. The southern part of R Eulaeus is now called Palaeo-Karun “K2”, and its northern part is modern R Karkheh. In Antiquity, there was a connection known as “Kh1” between the two rivers near present-day Ahwaz (Cole 2007, Walstra 2010, Heyvaert 2012). R Eulaeus is mentioned by Strabo, Pliny, Arrian, Marcian as connecting the city of Susa with R Tigris. Hence, R Tigris and R Eulaeus both flowed into Chaldaicus Lacus, enabling sailing upstream from the sea via R Pasitigris to the lake, and then via R Eulaeus to Susa.
The following places may be considered as ports on R Eulaeus:
- Susa, Shushan, Seleucia ad Eulaeum, is located between two rivers: R Eulaeus, Choaspes (modern R Karkheh) and R Koprates (modern R Dez). This very old city was a regional capital where Alexandre-the-Great met his fleet admiral, Nearchus, when returning from the Indus Valley.
- Aginis is mentioned solely by Arrian during Nearchus’ journey from Chaldaicus Lacus to Susa, placing it 500 stadia (about 90 km) from Susa. It might therefore be located on a tell in the area the modern Karkheh Deviation Dam (e.g., 31.557°N, 48.493°E).
- Charax Spasinou, Spasinu Caras, Charax of Hyspaosines, Alexandria, Antiochia, Maysan on Mesanites Sinus? Emporium mentioned by Strabo = Naisan, Jebel Khayabir, about 18 km SE of el-Qurnah. This city was strategically situated on the lake and R Tigris, at the outlet of R Eulaeus, serving as an emporium where seagoing ships and riverboats could converge for the exchange and transfer of goods (Cole, 2007, Walstra, 2010, Heyvaert, 2012, Moon, 2016).
R Pasitigris = Shatt el-Arab, around 150 km long from the supposed outlet of the Chaldaicus Lacus. The following places may be considered as ports on R Pasitigris:
- Forat = Maghlub, about 16 km SE of Charax (Cole, 2007).
- Apologos, Marcian’s Coromane? Ptolemy’s Koromanis? = al-Ubullah? al-Abelah? al-Ashar in Bassora, Basra? This port is mentioned solely by the anonymous author of the “Periplus Maris Erythraei” and its location, probably around Bassora, is very uncertain (Salles, 2012).
R Mogaeus, Mogeus, Mogaios, Mosaios = This river is mentioned only by Marcian, at 700 stadia (130 km) downstream of Charax. This distance is perhaps somewhat exaggerated as it leads to Bahar not far from the modern sea outlet of the Shatt el-Arab. The mouth of the modern R Karun at Khorramshahr would be a better candidate at only 500 stadia from Charax. In this hypothetical case, R Mogaeus would correspond to the “K3-K3b” track of R Karun (Heyvaert, 2013, fig. 3) supposing that the “modern” Karun course was already operational in Marcian’s time (5th c. CE).
R Hedyphon =R Jarrahi, called R Marun, Maroon further upstream. Its hypothetical ancient outlet might have been near Khor Musa (Heyvaert, 2013, fig. 3): following the “J2” track starting west of Tell Tendy (30.8548°N, 49.4717°E). Note that the “J1” track might be much older than “J2”, and modern “J3” is too recent. The “J2” choice is very hypothetical and ancient authors do not mention it. This outlet might explain the muddy shallows mentioned by Nearchus, as this river seems to carry much sediment.
Kataderbis Lake = Khor Musa (very hypothetically). Nearchus mentions a lake full of fish where his fleet anchored for the night (Arrian, 8, 41). Its access was rather narrow, as they had to sail in a single line when leaving the next morning. Dangerous muddy shallows were encountered at the lake exit and marked by wooden poles by local sailors.
Margastana insula = Bandar-e Emam Khomeyni, inside Khor Musa (very hypothetically). This island is mentioned by Nearchus (Arrian, 8, 41) and located at the entrance of Kataderbis Lake. Potts (1999) mentions Bandar Mahshahr as unlikely because it is not an island today. It is nevertheless an old 3rd c. CE city. Perhaps nearby Bandar-e Emam Khomeyni is a better candidate.
Similarly to the above description of Margastana insula and Kataderbis Lake, Marcian (1, 21) mentions a Taxiana insula, located in front of Sinus Pelodes, lake Palode, Sinus Steloas. Again very hypothetically, it is tempting to consider Arrian and Marcian are talking about the same places.
R Arosis, R Oroatis, R Shirin = R Zohreh, where Nearchus anchored (Arrian, 8, 39, Marcian, 1, 21). This is the most easterly river to be mentioned in the delta of the Tigris-Euphrates.
The map below provides an attempt at a synthesis, but the last word is obviously far from being said…
References
Blackman, D. (1982). Ancient Harbours in the Mediterranean, Part 1. International Journal of Nautical Archaeology, 1, 79–104. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1095-9270.1982.tb00064.x
Cole, S., & Gasche, H. (2007). Documentary and Other Archaeological and Environmental Evidence Bearing on the Identification and Location of the Rivers of Lower Khuzestan and the Position of the Head of the Persian Gulf, ca. 1200 BC – 200 AD. In The Persian Gulf Shorelines and the Karkheh, Karun, and Jarrahi Rivers: A Geo-Archaeological Approach: Vol. Part 3 (pp. 5–72). https://www.academia.edu/7531835/
Curtis, J., Raheed, Q. H., Clarke, H., Hamdani, A. M. A., Stone, E., Van Ess, M., Collins, P., & Ali, M. (2008). An Assessment of Archaeological Sites in June 2008: An Iraqi-British Project. Iraq, 70, 215–237.
D’Agostino, F., & Romano, L. (2013). Abu Tbeirah. Preliminary Report of the 2012-2013 Campaigns. 9th International Congress on the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East (ICAANE), Basel (Switzerland). https://www.academia.edu/25715089/
Heyvaert, V. M. A., Verkinderen, P., & Walstra, J. (2013). Geoarchaeological Research in Lower Khuzestan: State of the Art. In Susa and Elam. Archaeological, Philological, Historical and Geographical Perspectives (pp. 493–534). Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004207417_029
Heyvaert, V. M. A., Walstra, J., Verkinderen, P., Weerts, H. J. T., & Ooghe, B. (2012). The role of human interference on the channel shifting of the Karkheh River in the Lower Khuzestan plain (Mesopotamia, SW Iran). Quaternary International, 251, 52–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2011.07.018
Moon, J. (2016). Charax Spasinou – Alexander’s lost city in Iraq. https://www.charaxspasinou.org/
Pawlicki, F. (2016). Preliminary report on the archaeological survey of the joint Kuwaiti–Polish Mission, Failaka Island, 2012. Polish Archaeology in the Mediterranean, XXIV, 547–559. https://doi.org/10.5604/01.3001.0010.0093
Potts, D. T. (1999). The islands of the XIVth Satrapy. In Oetjen, R., ed. New perspectives in Seleucid history, archaeology and numismatics: Studies in honor of Getzel M. Cohen. Berlin: Beiträge zur Altertumskunde 355. (pp. 375–396). https://www.academia.edu/41642340/
Salles, J.-F. (2012). Le Golfe persique dans le Périple de la mer Erythrée: Connaissances fondées et ignorances réelles ? TOPOI. Supplément. 11. Autour Du Périple de La Mer Érythrée / Ed. M.-Fr. Boussac, J.-Fr. Salles et J.-B. Yon. https://www.academia.edu/127152276/
Sanlaville, P. (1989). Considérations sur l’évolution de la Basse Mésopotamie au cours des derniers millénaires. Paléorient, 15(2), 5–27. https://doi.org/10.3406/paleo.1989.4506
Sauvage, M. (2020). Atlas historique du Proche-Orient ancien. https://www.lesbelleslettres.com/livre/9782251451138/atlas-historique-du-proche-orient-ancien
Schoff, W., & Marcianus of Heraclea. (1927). Periplus of the Outer Sea, East and West, and of the Great Islands Therein. Commercial museum.
Vincent, W. (1739-1815) A. du texte, & Wales, W. (1734?-1798) A. du texte. (1797). Voyage de Néarque, des bouches de l’Indus jusqu’à l’Euphrate, ou Journal de l’expédition de la flotte d’Alexandre , rédigé sur le journal original de Néarque conservé par Arrien, à l’aide des éclaircissemens puisés dans les écrits et relations des auteurs, géographes ou voyageurs, tant anciens que modernes, et contenant l’histoire de la première navigation que les Européens aient tentée dans la mer des Indes. Traduit de l’anglois de William Vincent, par J.-B.-L.-J. Billecocq,… https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k5657594s
Walstra, J., Verkinderen, P., & Heyvaert, V. (2010). Reconstructing landscape evolution in the Lower Khuzestan plain (SW Iran): Integrating imagery, historical and sedimentary archives. In Developments in Earth Surface Processes (Vol. 15, pp. 111–128). https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-444-53446-0.00022-7